Would Leafs Give Babcock Control?


TORONTO (Apr. 12) — In the National Football League, it’s called “Black Monday” — 24 hours after the final regular–season games in early–January when lousy teams jettison managers and coaching staffs.

“Black Sunday” has occurred here in Toronto with the Maple Leafs, who fired general manager David Nonis and interim head coach Peter Horachek before aisles at the Air Canada Centre could be ridden of hot dog wrappers from the season finale last night. The first move was mildly surprising; the second, a foregone conclusion. It’s the third move, however, that will shape the immediate future of the hockey club.

Brendan Shanahan may already have a succession plan. Clearly, he didn’t wake up this morning and decide to rinse Nonis. In fact, the decision to clean house was probably made long before Nonis pulled the magic trick of unloading David Clarkson’s albatross on Columbus, Feb. 26 — a shocking development that many in the media concluded would salvage employment for the Toronto GM. I haven’t a clue what Shanahan is thinking, nor does anyone outside his immediate circle with the Blue and White. If I’m the Leafs president, however, my eyes are focused on Mike Babcock like a pair of laser beams. Perhaps they have been all along. But, with a managerial opening, the Leafs now have a grand opportunity to entice Babcock with a unique and practical dual position.



As soon as Detroit is either eliminated from the playoffs or wins the Stanley Cup, I open the Maple Leaf Sports and Entertainment vault and ask Babcock to become director of hockey operations, general manager and head coach. In conjunction with Shanahan, I provide Babcock control of all hockey–related matters… and a six–year, iron–clad contract worth $30 million. That way, Babcock, the GM, won’t have to make any short–term decisions to save Babcock, the coach. Nor will he be concerned about hiring another person to replace Horachek.

Detractors will say that hockey is too “busy” these days to provide one man the dual portfolio. But, the Leafs are in a unique position whereby Shanahan has filled virtually all of the necessary support functions. Kyle Dubas and Mark Hunter know the junior hockey scene backward and forward. Dubas heads up a department of hockey analytics. Brandon Pridham is the so–called “capologist” — maneuvering the variables of a payroll ceiling that may decrease marginally before next season. Dave Morrison remains as director of amateur scouting; Reid Mitchell and Steve Staios (slotted into an assistant coaching role after Randy Carlyle was fired) are quality hockey minds that coordinate scouting and player advisement. Director of pro scouting Steve Kasper and director of player development Jim Hughes were also fired today. As GM, Babcock would merely become the “boss” of those still in place. Heavy lifting would be done by these individuals (and others he and Shanahan bring in), with Babcock obtaining the rights of approval and veto in hockey decisions.

It would enable him to largely concentrate on his coaching duties.

This blog obviously pre–supposes that Babcock will leave Detroit after the current season. He has not uttered a syllable to suggest that, or otherwise. We can therefore only assume that the future Hall of Fame coach might be open to a fresh challenge — one that would allow him substantial development of a once–storied team that is now looking upward from near–bottom. Five–million dollars per season — over six years — would give Babcock continued employment security and placate his desire to become the highest–paid coach in the National Hockey League. Cast–iron moldings of his frame would be on stand–by for the moment the Leafs end their interminable championship drought.

The two key positions are open.

Money is not an issue (or, it shouldn’t be).

Now, let’s see if Brendan Shanahan has the power of persuasion.





9 comments on “Would Leafs Give Babcock Control?

  1. When Babcock joined the Red Wings the winning program and a strong farm club playing the “Detroit System” was well entrenched. If he were to come to Toronto that system is going to take a minimum of four seasons while reaching the winning levels for the “Big Club” in the NHL.

  2. Typical swing for the fences type hurry up and build move. The type of move that if any of the other 29 teams were to consider, we would think they were nuts, but somehow because it’s the all mighty and righteous Maple Leafs we can pull off these kinds of things don’t you know!!!

  3. Babcock, won’t be coming to the Leafs anytime soon, Detroit has a slew of young talent in their system. Anybody seen Joe the Crow?

  4. While Babcock would be good for Toronto you have to wonder why he would want to expose himself to a toxic media, fickle fan base and a dysfunctional ownership combination when he’ll be able to command similar max dollars from another organization with far more stability, security and sanity!

  5. Had to be done, BUT, who would come in with the two assistant GM’s still there? Isn’t this the same old, same old? Should it not be, the GM hires his assistants etc. etc. I just hope this movie is not one we’ve seen before!

  6. Well, now then…there ya go…Hughes, Kasper and all the scouting staff have been fired…haven’t heard if George Armstrong is among those as he is on the scouting list

  7. Let me play Devil’s Advocate…
    1st Would a coach who’s used to winning want to lose big for at least 3 years…?
    As GM would he “push” to provide small shortcuts for the Coach (himself)?
    As to Morrison, Kasper, Hughes, Mitchell, Staios etc. they are partly responsible for the present team and it’s weak farm system…if I were Babcock I would not have much confidence in that group…
    Finally, the semi-toxic media (yes, I believe this exists) & ownership atmosphere here in Toronto …

  8. By the sounds of things the Leafs’ scouts will be the next heads to roll. I am glad they are dropping the axe on everything in sight. I fully agree they need to open up the war chest and throw whatever they have to get Babcock steering this ship. Hopefully he brings a piece of Detroit’s drafting success with him, and has his say in a new scouting team as well. In the next 3 years, who the Leafs pick is equally important to who coaches them.

    Great read!

Comments are closed.

This site is protected by Comment SPAM Wiper.