Must Be Those Irish Eyes in the Sky

TORONTO (May 6) — May I suggest we change the name of the Leafs’ new senior advisor to Mats O’Sundin. Nothing could more–perfectly offer tribute to the spirit responsible for that bonkers draft–lottery win last night.

Of course it was the Big Irishman.

Steadfastly arriving to the rescue of his long–time captain–cum–executive; looking down on Maple Leaf rooters with confused empathy after Monday’s disastrous media wag. “I can’t allow Mats to enter such a downtrodden situation,” said Pat Quinn to himself; pausing near the pearly gates to organize his ultimate move. “Coming all the way from Sweden with his family. It’s just not right. He was a wonderful captain and human being during our eight years in Toronto. I don’t know much about the other guy (John Chayka)… but I really need to help. Hmmmm…

“Maybe I can do something with that No. 12 lottery ball.”


Okay, you explain it.

Against near–impossible odds and after more than a year of gripping over the No. 6 draft selection going to Boston, the Maple Leafs moved up to No. 1. Just like that. The No. 12 lottery ball made a first and sudden appearance. Leafs Nation vaulted from floor to ceiling in the blink of an eye. Entirely unwarranted, of course, for the hockey club after its core players quit on yet another coach and brought the club down to 28th of 32 teams in the National Hockey League standings. By all rights, the Bruins should have nailed down that top half–dozen pick granted by Brad Treliving, 14 months ago, in the trade for Brandon Carlo. But, nothing of the sort materialized.

Not with that cigar–munching four–leaf clover in the sky.

Now, it’s up to Chayka and O’Sundin — we think — to convert last night’s gift into all of the club’s necessities. That’s how monstrous a moment it was when Toronto’s number came up. Given timely and shrewd decisions, the culture malaise that crippled the team in the playoffs every year (and the regular schedule this past year) can be sent awash like a tidal wave. That is, of course, if Chayka and O’Sundin are allowed to be motivated with maneuvering the club into Stanley Cup contention. And, not compromised by corporate shenanigans aimed at the bottom line (such as licensed apparel). If Ed the Conqueror and Keith Pelley wisely step out of the way, there is legitimate hope for not only a reversal of fortune, but sustained prosperity. And, it doesn’t absolutely need to begin with Penn State wiz Gavin McKenna. When the dust clears, however, Chayka and O’Sundin must emerge — one way or another — with the elite blue–line prospect the club has been devoid of for nearly half–a–century, since the late Borje Salming skated in his prime. Without which, it cannot challenge for the NHL title. How absurd that the Maple Leafs have neglected this mandatory requirement for such a massive portion of the 109–year franchise.

Until Monday, there would have been absolutely no question about Maple Leaf Sports and Entertainment making it clear to those underneath that McKenna be chosen first; the No. 72 Leaf jerseys already in production. I’m going to assume, however, that Chayka is intimately aware of the interminable blue line deficit. And, will venture to solve the issue — either by overlooking McKenna and choosing the top–rated defenseman (I hear magnificent things about Carson Carels of the Western Hockey League Prince George Cougars) or by obtaining a top blue–line prospect via trade. Were the idle–averse Brian Burke still in charge of the Leafs, you know he’d already be working on Auston Matthews and William Nylander about their no–movement clauses. Fantasizing, no doubt, about San Jose desiring one of the two current Leafs in exchange for the second overall pick. Pulling off Sedin Twins magic, 27 years later. Macklin Celebrini and Willie Styles on the same forward unit? Could make for some exciting nights in NoCal. Thereby allowing the Leafs to select McKenna and the top–rated defenseman of their choice.

Does Chayka have Burke’s ample “set”?

More importantly, would he be granted authority by MLSE to engage with Nylander and Matthews? Not based on Pelley’s “foundational pieces” declaration of Mar. 31; none of which, by the way, was repeated during Monday’s conference. Otherwise, Chayka and O’Sundin have been granted an unexpected opportunity to wash away the culture that has held back the Leafs. By doing whatever possible to encourage No. 34 of a change; working with Matthews (who probably wouldn’t protest) so the Leafs and a trading partner are satisfied. I would pursue a similar tactic with Nylander, though not as urgently. Morgan Rielly would need to waive the remainder of his contract with the Leafs… or move to the front of the buyout line. Believe it or not, there is a path for the Leafs to begin next season in the absence of their somnolent core pieces. All of them. Replaced with the consensus top prospect in the draft (McKenna); perhaps a second pick near the top (Nylander or Matthews going to the Sharks) or a trade involving the two current Leaf stars that lands an elite defense prospect. As mentioned, one way or another, Chayka and O’Sundin cannot emerge from this process without that essential component. Given the past struggles, drafting McKenna won’t be enough. From what I can assertain, he has the potential to replace Mitch Marner’s numbers. But, how did the Leafs fair in the Stanley Cup hunt with a passive, 100–point forward? You know the answer.


Neither will this process lead to immediate answers on the ice. It doesn’t have to. With McKenna… and an elite defense hopeful obtained via trade, the proper foundation will be in place. No more loading up on soft, talented forwards that shine from October to April… and then disappear. A smart, puck–moving rearguard (Carels?) abosultely must become part of the mix. Or, it’ll be more of the same for the Leafs and their legion of followers.

Other challenges remain. Such as sorting out, at last, the goaltending conundrum. And, assuring the future of the club is in solid coaching hands, without concern over paying out two years of an existing contract.

Call Tuesday night’s magic what you want. Perhaps the luck of the Swedish.

But, never, ever underestimate that cigar–chomping Leprechaun in the sky.

EMAIL: HOWARDLBERGER@GMAIL.COM

6 comments on “Must Be Those Irish Eyes in the Sky”

  1. Thank you for being a voice of reason while all the other “pundits” keep talking about how the Leafs should convince Matthews to stay. Can you imagine!

  2. The Leafs should gauge San Jose’s interest in Gavin McKenna, and if they want him bad enough, see if they would swap picks in exchange for Sam Dickenson coming to the Leafs and Morgan Reiily going back the other way, then the Leafs could pick 1A Ivar Stenberg, have a big 6’3″ 19 yr old developing top 4 defenseman in Dickenson for years to come, then sign Raddysh. I would also try to move Matthews no matter what, he has had 10 years to deliver, time for both sides to part ways

  3. “By all rights”…the Bruin’s charmed fortunes (in EVERY deal made between the two teams spanning nearly 2 decades now) had to come to an end eventually. Kessel for Seguin and Hamilton, Rask for Raycroft, Carlo for Minten AND the 6th overall? Now THAT is the lottery balls dropping in your favour, but who knows. The 2028 draft is yet to come!

  4. The fellow Hamiltonian should have won a cup. He deserved it. Hopefully they don’t pick McKenna. McKenna is a small winger that doesn’t play well without the puck. Doesn’t kill penalties, not a two way forward. Could easily be a flop. This draft is deep in puck moving defencemen. Get the best one. Carson Carels is a Manitoba farm boy. On the ice he does it all.

    1. I share your thoughts Brother.
      I’m hoping that Toronto trades down to the 2nd, 3rd, or 4th spot for a 2026 first, a proven defender, and a second 2026 second (or higher). I’m mildly obsessed with Keaton Verhoeff. Our new GM should be shopping the pick to see what he can get.
      McKenna could a superstar, but then again may be just a good player …. verdict is still out.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by Comment SPAM Wiper.