Soo Reunion in Goal For Leafs?

TORONTO (Oct. 4) — Over the past few days, I have warmed to the notion of Maple Leafs general manager Kyle Dubas re–uniting with the goalie tandem from his first season running the Sault Ste. Marie Greyhounds of the Ontario Hockey League. One stopper 28; the other still 26 with a pair of Stanley Cup rings. Both, in my view, an upgrade over Frederik Anderson, who has regularly come up small in the playoff crunch, convincing the Toronto brass that it’s time for a change. Yes, there will be innumerable options for Dubas this off–season… and neither do we know if, or when, there will be a next season. But, something about Matt Murray and Jack Campbell sharing the netminding load for the Blue and White smacks favorably with me.

For this to happen, there are two requirements: First, and foremost, Dubas has to make another trade with Pittsburgh counterpart Jim Rutherford. In late–August, the Maple Leafs sent winger Kasperi Kapanen to the Penguins for a 2020 first–round draft pick (15th overall). Second, hockey observers here in Toronto need to look beyond the numbers of the past three years, which were not flattering to Murray, now a restricted free agent. He was terrific for the Penguins in the Stanley Cup drives of 2016 and 2017 — posting a 2.08 goals–against average and .923 save–percentage in 21 appearances when Pittsburgh defeated San Jose for the first Cup; he then shared the load with Marc–Andre Fleury the following year (1.70 / .937 in 11 appearances) as Pittsburgh bested Nashville in the Cup final. Over three springs (2016–18), Murray won 28 playoff matches.

Andersen has 10 playoff victories in the past four years with the Maple Leafs.


As to why Murray has fallen off since 2016–17, there is no particular answer. Neither has there been goaltending stability in Pittsburgh, with Fleury, Murray, Casey DeSmith and Tristan Jarry all vying for the No. 1 role. It appears that Jarry has won the confidence of Rutherford after signing a three–year contract extension with a $3.5 million cap–hit on Saturday. “Tristan is coming off of an All–Star season and has demonstrated the ability to be a regular starter for us,” said Rutherford, who admitted it would be “difficult” to keep Jarry and Murray. Were Pittsburgh not up against the payroll ceiling ($2,634,825 beneath, according to, perhaps Rutherford would accept the final year of Andersen’s contract ($5 million cap–hit) for Murray. Both might benefit from a change of scenery and Andersen’s actual salary next season is only $1 million. This could still be a possibility if Rutherford were to clear money elsewhere — a requirement in any commensurate deal for Murray. Otherwise, Pittsburgh would go with Jarry and DeSmith in goal.

The Leafs could try and entice Rutherford by returning that first–round pick to the Penguins. From a Toronto perspective, would a two–time Stanley Cup winner with excellent playoff stats (29 wins, 2.18 / .921) be worth the No. 15 selection in the upcoming draft? I’d say it’s a fairly safe gamble. Murray is plenty young enough to regenerate his career and would likely not break the bank when signing a new contract with the Leafs. If Dubas could trade for Murray and lock him up for five years at a cap–hit of, say, $4 million, the Maple Leafs would spent a total of $5,165,000 on both goalies for the next two years, before Campbell’s deal expires.

Any trade, of course, for Murray would be predicated on the Leafs unloading the final year of Andersen’s contract. Which isn’t a red–light emergency given that we don’t know when the next National Hockey League season will begin. Calgary is clearly looking for help between the pipes with 35–year–old Cam Talbot an unrestricted free agent and 28–year–old Dave Rittich (2.97 / .907 last season in 48 appearances) signed for one more year. Andersen is just reaching prime years for a goalie in the NHL (early–30’s) and, again, would benefit from a change. He could provide the Flames a stop–gap, and some experience, before top goaltending prospect Dustin Wolf graduates to the bigs. Wolf, 19, was goalie–of–the–year in the Western Hockey League with Everett, posting a 1.88 GAA in 46 appearances (1.69 two seasons ago in 61 games). He could become the steal of the 2019 draft, when Calgary unearthed him in the seventh round, 214th overall.

If I’m the Leafs, I’d be happy to accept a second or third–round pick for Andersen; then flip this year’s first–rounder to Pittsburgh for Murray, who won’t cost as much as UFA stoppers like Braden Holtby (Washington), Jacob Markstrom (Vancouver) or Anton Khudobin (Dallas). Murray and Campbell could form a competitive — and still young — tandem for the Leafs, adding, to Toronto, some valued playoff accomplishment.


A sampling of opinion from just prior to the 1985–86 NHL season:




6 comments on “Soo Reunion in Goal For Leafs?

  1. Far fetched for sure but something “blockbuster” is also needed here. Offer Austin Matthews straight up to the Rangers (if of course they are willing) for their number one pick. Buys the Leafs the money they need to shore up the D with one, or possibly two quality right hand shots. The Rangers need a centre or two. Then flip the number one pick with LA for number two ( and perhaps a roster center to fill the gap) and take Quinton Byfield at number two. He’s physical which is exactly what the Buds need and can step in right away. Far fetched – for sure – but something like this is what the Leafs have to do. Get creative and pull a Masai Ujiri!

  2. Howard I’m wracking my brain trying to figure out how Toronto is going to pull the rabbit out of the hat ….. Much like President Trump came down with Covid (allegedly) flipping public sediment to win the 2020 election.

    Personally, I like the pick if they are able to get Braden Schneider. I’d like to see Reilly as the offensive dman paired with a behemoth dman who likes to hit, clear the trash out in front of the net, and get the puck out of the defensive zone. For me Schneider ticks all the boxes. He’s 210 pounds but if Dubas signs up for boxing lessons and a subscription to the Chinese Mandrin “All you can eat daily Buffet” he’ll be pushing 225 (or more) by the time the season opens.

    Prying Shea Webber, OEL, or Seth Jones via trade seem enticing or signing the leaning tower of Chara might plug the hole and free up the pick.

  3. This is just my two cents, but I really believe Campbell is going to surprise a lot of people, and emerge as the Leafs #1, IF he is given the chance. Let’s see what happens.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by Comment SPAM Wiper.