What Is Auston/Leafs’ Mindset?

TORONTO (May 16) — Whatever roster/salary cap manipulation the Toronto Maple Leafs are considering from this point forward absolutely must involve Auston Matthews. Not solely because he failed to help lift the club beyond one playoff round for a sixth consecutive year. But, more as a result of the contract the Leafs accorded him on Feb. 5, 2019: a five–year, $58.17 million pact that consumed only one year of unrestricted free agency.

It allows for Matthews to test the open market in the summer of 2024, when he enters his biological prime. Far more urgently is a no–movement clause that kicks in just more than a year from now (July 1, 2023), when Matthews is eligible to sign a contract extension. At which point the player holds all the cards. He cannot be traded without consent and the Maple Leafs will garner no return if he decides to choose another team a year later. Undoubtedly, his next contract will span the maximum eight–year term, ushering Matthews into his mid–30’s. So, it’s mandatory that the Leafs and their top goal–scorer begin to determine the position of each side.

Unless the Maple Leafs are impotent lap dogs and will throw themselves at Matthews’ feet, an onerous decision lurks on the not–too–distant horizon. From the club’s perspective, how does more than a half–decade of playoff deficiency govern whether to provide Matthews a career–long guarantee in the Big Smoke? And, from the player’s standpoint, is Auston starting to consider the cliché–like bromide that “there’s a limit to everything?” With a franchise–record and National Hockey League–best 60 goals, followed by another quick exit from the Stanley Cup tournament, is Matthews pondering an eventual change of scenery? It is virtually assured that he’ll divulge nothing about his future when the Maple Leafs gather with the media on Tuesday and clean out their lockers. Nor should we expect any form of declaration from general manager Kyle Dubas. Instead, we’ll hear how Matthews loves it in Toronto and cannot imagine playing elsewhere, with similar tidings from Kyle and Co.

But, the actual stakes broaden with each day. Starting now.


Complicating matters is that Mitch Marner also becomes unmovable on July 1, 2023 and — more significantly — a limited no–movement clause takes effect with William Nylander, who can submit to the Leafs a list of 10 cities to which he cannot be traded (more on Nylander later). One year in professional sport is the veritable blink of an eye. It was one playoff attempt ago that the Leafs were embarrassed by the Montreal Canadiens. If you’re a fan of the club, doesn’t that seem like only yesterday? Well, it’s the time remaining before Matthews, unbound by restriction, can dictate his future to the Maple Leafs… and, possibly, take his wonderful goal–scoring exploits to another city. Under no circumstance, naturally, will the Leafs allow that to happen. Which could result in one of the most–compelling, momentous trades in the now 105–year history of the Blue and White. Implausible though it seems.

The gut response from Leafs Nation, of course, will be “aw, he’s not going anywhere. Auston will sign with Toronto for life.” Which is hardly inconceivable, especially if Dubas remains in the GM’s chair. Though he’s built an exceptional club between October and April, Kyle has shown absolutely no compunction to tinker with his beloved core.

Which begs the question, perhaps rhetorical: Can he make a tough, strategic call that involves players with whom he’s emotionally invested? Already, one cheerleader in the local media has granted a parochial view (with more surely to follow). Wrote Toronto Star columnist Chris Johnston (who doubles as an insider with Leafs–owned TSN): “Really, this is about Matthews and what needs to happen over the next 13–plus months to ensure he’s eager to sign another contract [with the Maple Leafs] at the earliest available opportunity.” That offering is so ‘Toronto’: “Lock up our hero forever… even if it means 16 consecutive years of first–round playoff elimination.”

Continued Johnston: “Unless, of course, the team decides to trade him by June 30, 2023 — but how could the Leafs possibly even consider doing that with one of the sport’s most–unique talents, unless he indicates a desire to test the open waters a full year before he can actually hit the market? They can’t, and he won’t.” More proof that Johnston, as with so many Maple Leaf followers, has been conned and bamboozled by regular–season accomplishment. Dubas, Brendan Shanahan and the decision makers need to think more broadly… as should, quite frankly, a columnist with Canada’s largest newspaper. But, we exist in a fishbowl–type environment in which far too many observers in the Toronto media talk and write as an extension of the hockey club. It is truly a shame.

Fact remains that the Leafs have accomplished nothing with Matthews on board. He has unlimited skill with the puck and does provide immense value to the club and its ticket patrons during the 82–game playoff warmup. Once the stakes increase, however, he is (to this point) incapable of lifting the Leafs even marginally, in the manner of Darryl Sittler, Doug Gilmour and Mats Sundin. Or, the way Connor McDavid carried the Edmonton Oilers past the stubborn Los Angeles Kings and into the first Battle of Alberta since 1991. After six failed attempts, there is no arguing the matter. What remains to be determined is how many more times the club — and the player — wish to venture down the same, desultory path. If we hear another version from Dubas, on Tuesday, of “we’ll get this done” or “we believe in the group”, you can predict the outcome. But, to suggest, as did Johnston, that the Leafs absolutely, positively cannot move forward beyond next season without Matthews is nothing shy of myopic.


I was 6–2 in the first round of the Stanley Cup playoffs, missing with St. Louis (I chose Minnesota) and Carolina (I chose Boston). Here is my forecast for Round 2, which begins Tuesday night (HOME–ICE team in caps):

Tampa Bay over FLORIDA in 7
CAROLINA over New York Rangers in 6

COLORADO over St. Louis in 7
CALGARY over Edmonton in 7


7 comments on “What Is Auston/Leafs’ Mindset?

  1. I would love to see Auston Matthews be a Maple Leaf for life; however, you make an excellent point Howard. I haven’t seen him dominate in games when everything is on the line.
    Boston traded Joe Thornton and Tyler Seguin when they felt they couldn’t win with them. They have won the Stanley Cup and went to the finals multiple times with players who have the intangibles to win.

  2. I’m not convinced the ownership really cares whether or not the team wins anything. I think they are more concerned with having a “star” player like Matthews to use as branding for the team. As others have very presciently pointed out (and this is for you analytical types) there is not a team in the east semi-finals with a player making over $10 M. None of the teams have a forward making over $9.5 M. The top forward in Carolina makes $8.5 M and in Florida, even less. Tampa’s Victor Hedman, arguably the best defenceman in the NHL, makes far less than any of Matthews, Warner or Tavares. So this team needs to get its cap situation under control. However, as I stated earlier, I don’t believe there is any urgency at the ownership level to actually win anything.

  3. I’d hate to be in Dubas’ shoes right about. To be honest he really has no choice to run it back with his core 5. However, because of the tight Salary Cap he will need to reconfigure the supporting cast in order to remain Cap compliant. Pridham, Gilman and the not so young anymore, Maple Leafs GM have their work cut out for themselves. With only 3 picks in the draft and limited available Salary Cap space this management team will need to divest the team of Mrazek’s anchor of a contract and cut out the middle class on this roster to reshape this team. It’s imperative that they continue to uncover valuable but affordable pieces like Bunting, Kampf, Kase and Mikheyev. That’s a tall order.

  4. It’s now time for a new President and a new GM. No one is holding anyone in the Leaf organization accountable – which is a travesty. Forget the excuses, forget the refs and bad calls, forget the “how even” the series was or “we were that close”, the fact is Tampa Bay beat the Leafs. Now 0 for 6 in first series losses, 0 for 9 in close out to win the series games, and 0 for 18 on the PP in close out the series to win games with this regime. It is what it is – failure. The guy down the hall made a decision in 2018 that ultimately won a championship. A controversial move at the time, but he knew he had to make one or more to get over a difficult hump. Brendan and Kyle will not, and cannot, detach emotionally in order to see what has to be done to turn the assets and contention window they have today into a team that can win a round or two and eventually contend for the Cup. They got it to this point, but they prove incapable of making the difficult moves to get over the difficult hump. Retooling every year to compensate for the now core 5 isn’t going to get this team to the promised land. Oh, and Soupy’s going to want more now which will make it even more difficult to manoeuvre to sign the “transient” pieces they gamble on every year. There is only one way to get out of this cyclical mess, and that’s getting a new Management Team in place that will make the necessary moves, and not box itself further into a corner year every with no way out. It will be a shame if Dubas faces the media for the annual post mortem – it means he and his boss are still in control and more of the same “I believe in this group” excuses will roll but yet again.

  5. Howard – thanks for the insights. After so many years of hollow victories and delusion, I question the Leaf organization’s motivation and scratch my head about the incompetence. They either don’t really want or care about winning it all or say they do but don’t know how. I don’t care who they keep and who goes – Matthews, Marner or Carlton the Bear. I want a Stanley Cup once in my lifetime. I’m 55 and don’t think I’ll ever see one.

    1. I’m right there with you. 52 and still waiting. Afraid that I won’t see a Cup in my lifetime. So many pieces have to come together at the same time. Very difficult with the cap.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by Comment SPAM Wiper.